Sunday, January 20, 2013

Parshas Beshalach - A curious Rashi


“And it was when Pharoah sent out the nation that God did not lead them by the way of the land of the Philistines, which was near, for God said: ‘Perhaps the people will reconsider when they see a war and they will return to Egypt.’     So God turned the people toward the way of the Wilderness to the Sea of Reeds. And the children of Israel chamushim when they went up from the land of Egypt.”
Shemos 13:17-18

The Biblical commentators grapple with the meaning of the Hebrew word, Chamushim, in the middle of verse 18; apparently, it is either an uncommon word or one that is not simple to translate in this context. Rashi, as do a few others (such as Seforno and Rabbi Samso Raphael Hirsch), translate the word as “armed”. As a proof Rashi notes that the Children of Israel later engage in a number of wars, with Amalek in Sefer Shemos (Exodus) and with Sichon, Og, and Midian in Sefer BaMidbar (Numbers). This verse, then, is merely providing background information on where the Jewish people got their armaments.

The question we could ask on this comment of Rashi is – why is this information offered now? And why is it offered here? Wouldn’t it have made more sense to include this information in the recounting, one chapter earlier (in Parshas Bo), of the different things the Jews took with them when they left Egypt – silver and gold items they Egyptians gave them, unbaked dough that became matzoh, and a lot of livestock (Shemos 12: 34-39)?

Ramban (Nachmonidies) offers one possible way to understand the placement of this information in this week’s Parsha. In his commentary on this verse Ramban, citing the Ibn Ezra, suggests that the Jews regarded the weapons they took as triumphant proof that they were redeemed by God as opposed to escaped slaves (who would, presumably, not have access to weapons stockpiles). This information is placed in this parsha because shortly thereafter we see the Jewish people’s triumphant attitude melt away quickly when they notice the Egyptian military bearing down on them as they encamp at the Red Sea (14:11). The information that they were armed is placed here to tell us a distinct message – that no matter what tools or toys we hold, our self-regard can change in an instant. The only sure factor that offers us protection against a range of dangers is our devotion to God.   

No comments:

Post a Comment